Project Management Tips

Better Project Management - Today!

Free PM Tips





Advertisement

RSS Feeds

Software Blogs - Blog Catalog Blog Directory

Home

PMO Interview Questions

User Rating: / 1
Written by Andy Makar   
Monday, 22 December 2008
Interviewing candidates for a PMO position is different than hiring for a project manager position. The fundamental skill sets are similar, but the leadership skills and technical competencies are influenced by the form and function performed by the PMO. The PMO may exist at a program, department or enterprise level, and the project managers working with the PMO may have a strong or weak matrix relationship with the PMO manager. The following interview questions are just a few that can be used to staff PMOs at various levels in an organization. They should be tailored according to the specific PMO’s form and function.
 
Question 1: Portfolio Management and Governance
Describe how you’ve implemented portfolio management across an organization. What tools have you used to manage the portfolio?
 
A key function within a program, department or enterprise PMO is the governance and management of the projects in the portfolio. An effective PMO assists in the decision-making process to identify, select and monitor the projects executing in the portfolio. Candidates should demonstrate previous experiences organizing portfolio reviews and supporting portfolio decision making. Candidates that have experience with project portfolio management tools like Clarity, Microsoft’s Project Portfolio Server or IBM’s Rational Portfolio Manager are an asset to the team.
 
Question 2: Schedule Management
Describe a recent experience integrating different schedules across related projects or programs. What is your approach to manage and track key milestones and deliverables across a program?
 
In a program level PMO, the related projects are integrated across milestones and the PMO assists the program manager in identifying late or at-risk milestones. The questions also help identify a PMO member’s approach to gather the information, integrate and report on the program or portfolio’s performance.
 
Question 3: Resource and Demand Management
How do you manage new project requests and determine the organization’s resource capacity?
 
Another key function that PMOs provide is resource management. At a department level, the PMO needs to manage the project initiation and resource utilization within the portfolio. PMO managers need to demonstrate the ability to manage the resource allocation and utilization within the portfolio in order to balance the demand for new work entering the pipeline.
 
Question 4: Quality and Tollgate Management
Describe a previous experience where you were responsible for process quality assurance. How do you ensure projects within the portfolio are following tollgates and obtain the necessary approvals to proceed?
 
In IT implementations, process quality assurance is implemented to ensure project teams are following the methodology and producing the required deliverables. By following consistent processes, consistent deliverables and ultimately consistent results can be expected. Candidates should cite experiences working with project teams to implement a methodology and ensure process steps are executed correctly.
 
As projects are executed across the portfolio, the PMO also needs to manage the various project tollgates and ensure all the stakeholders agree with the current progression of the project.
Successful candidates can provide experiences where they were responsible for communicating the key issues, risks and open-action items as projects progressed through the phase tollgates.
 
Question 5: Financial Management
Describe your experiences managing financial budgets. What was the scope and processes used to manage program or portfolio forecasts?
 
The financial management function may reside within the PMO or it may reside within a strategic planner function. If it resides in the PMO, these questions will help determine if the PMO candidate has previous experiences managing financial forecasts, tracking actual costs throughout a portfolio and monitoring the portfolio’s budget.
 
Question 6: Change Management
Describe your experiences implementing a change control board across a program or portfolio.
 
Understanding the change management processes in the PMBOK and applying a change management control board across a portfolio or program is an exercise in translating theory into practice. Scope and cost management are critical skills needed to effectively manage a program or portfolio. Effective candidates should demonstrate past experiences applying change management procedures and discuss some of the challenges found managing a change control board. Change control is critical when managing outsourced contracts with different vendors as well as managing scope within an internal program.
 
Question 7: Mentoring and Training
Describe an experience where you were responsible for coaching or training others on project management techniques.
 
Effective PMOs not only promote the project management practices within the organization but are able to coach, mentor and develop the project managers’ skill sets. Effective PMOs are staffed with resources that can deliver projects and successfully share their knowledge with junior project managers. Organizations have different levels of project management capability and PMOs help improve the capability by promoting and sharing project management best practices. Successful candidates should be able to cite past experiences sharing lessons learned, providing best practices or imparting methodology knowledge to other project managers.
 
These seven questions can be further augmented with the questions provided in the previous two articles that assess candidates’ technical- and leadership-based project management competencies. Please refer to the attached PMO interview guide and tailor it to your organization’s needs. For more information on the form and function of PMO, please read The PMO: Form and Function
 

Assessing Technical PM Competencies

User Rating: / 0
Written by Andy Makar   
Monday, 24 November 2008
In the previous article, we reviewed five effective leadership behavior questions. These questions were designed to assess delivery based leadership behaviors, and to help foster a commitment to customer satisfaction and a drive for overall delivery. This article provides a set of technical project management questions that assess the candidate’s knowledge of project management tools and techniques.

Technical Competencies

Question 1: What steps do you follow to build a project schedule? How do you baseline a project schedule in MS-project?

These questions assess the project manager’s schedule development skills.  The ideal candidate will walk through the steps to develop a project schedule including activity definition, sequencing, resource estimation, duration estimation and resource leveling. If the project manager can’t tell you how or when to baseline a project schedule using Microsoft Project or another scheduling tool, then it is an early indicator the candidate lack’s an important technical skill to execute the process.

Question 2:
What techniques do you use to monitor and control project work?

This question is used to assess how the project manager monitors the project, addresses schedule and cost variances, and controls the project through delivery. I’m hoping to hear the project manager schedules weekly project status meetings where project tasks are tracked against baseline dates and late tasks are reported. The interviewer should probe about the project management methodology, reporting techniques and any type of project metrics used to monitor and control the project.  The candidate doesn’t have to respond with the formulas for earned value management, but if they do, you know you’ve found someone who understands schedule variance and its impact on project delivery.

I have a personal bias to the importance of tracking and updating the project schedule. The project schedule is the key document that I use throughout all my programs and projects to ensure timely delivery. Project teams run the risk of missing key dates if they don’t actively monitor and control schedule variance. If you’re going to manage it, you need to measure it. Managing a project schedule provides the metrics to effectively manage progress. It is an administrative task, but it ensures the work will be tracked.

Question 3: Provide an example of how you’ve gathered business requirements for a project.

In IT, effective project managers understand requirements definition and requirements management. Poorly defined requirements result in poorly designed applications. If requirements are not managed appropriately, the project’s scope can grow out of control. Effective project managers have had past roles as business or systems analysts and can leverage those experiences to help gather business requirements.

Effective project managers can demonstrate usage of tools such as process flow diagrams, use case models, sequence diagrams and activity sequence diagrams to gather business requirements. A fully staffed IT project will have business and systems analysts available. However, effective project managers are knowledgeable in these techniques and tools and can apply them as necessary.

Question 4: Describe the SDLC methodologies you have applied to your projects. How do the PM processes support the methodology?

This question assesses the project manager’s knowledge of system development lifecycle methodologies and demonstrates knowledge of both adaptive and predictive lifecycles. Adaptive methodologies use iterative processes often found in the Rational Unified Process, agile development or extreme programming. Predictive lifecycles use waterfall centric models. Effective project managers know when to apply the various methodologies as well as align it to the supporting project management process. The project management question probes if the candidate understands that the SDLC methodology is the tool to deliver the project, while the standard lifecycle phases of Initiate, Plan, Execute, Control and Close support the chosen methodology.

Question 5: Describe the processes and tools you have used for software quality management.

This question focuses on the software quality management aspects within an IT project. The project manager may have a software test lead or test manager responsible assigned to the project. It is important for the project manager to understand the software testing process and the tools used to support software testing.

Project managers don’t need to be an expert in requirements traceability, unit, system, performance or user acceptance testing, but they should be knowledgeable in the process and its importance to delivering a quality product. At a minimum, project managers should understand requirement traceability from requirements definition through user acceptance testing. Without the traceability, the project runs the risk of missing test cases for key requirements.

If project managers demonstrate experience using industry tools like MercuryQualityCenter (formerly Test Director) or IBM’s Rational ClearQuest, it provides more validation of their technical software quality management competency. Understanding the tools available to support quality management is a useful skill set in any IT development role.

Question 6: Describe how you manage project issues and project risks.

Just like schedule management, the mechanics of issue tracking and issue resolution is an important success factor in project delivery. Project issues and risks need to be maintained in a project log and reviewed for action and resolution.

Candidates may respond that issues and risks are tracked as part of the project; however, the interviewer should probe for evidence of a review process. Effective project managers review the issue log each week with the project team and report the top issues with each status report. If the issue is logged and reviewed, project teams will not lose sight of the challenges requiring resolution.

Project managers should also describe how they identify risks, quantify the impacts, assess the probability and identify risk response plans. Risk identification and assessment workshops may be periodically conducted or at least reviewed as part of project status. Risk management is easy to overlook as teams are challenged with meeting schedule dates, creating deliverables and resolving project issues. Effective project managers will log the issues and risks, track their progress and continue to work the log. It is an administrative task that still needs to be performed to monitor and control the project.

This article and the previous one provided several useful questions to help guide interviewers to assess candidates’ leadership and technical project management competencies. The attached Project Manager Interview Guide can be used to record candidate responses and make a hiring decision.

If you are interviewing for a project management position, you may also want to read the article Mind Map Your Interview to help you further prepare for an upcoming interview. I also created a discussion thread in the Gantthead Discussion Board to capture any additional interview questions. I look forward to reading your responses!
Last Updated ( Monday, 24 November 2008 )
 

Effective Project Management Interview Questions

User Rating: / 0
Written by Andy Makar   
Saturday, 15 November 2008
Staffing IT project management teams with capable and competent project managers is a challenge. If the interview isn’t structured with effective questions, it can result in a poor hiring decision or a missed opportunity. Screening candidates on PMP certification is not enough to determine if they are an effective project manager. Due to the influx of PMP certification preparation courses, aspiring project managers can pass the PMP exam by taking a weekend course. The market has fostered a culture where certification is earned by training to a test rather than validating key leadership behaviors and technical competencies. Fortunately, the market doesn’t base the hire decision only on certifications.
 
Over the years, I’ve used the following key questions to help staff my project and program management teams. The questions help identify competent project managers that understand project management theory and also demonstrate the practical application. The questions are grouped into two categories--leadership behaviors and technical competencies. Project managers need to demonstrate a balance between the mechanics of project management and the leadership qualities required to deliver the project. This article addresses the leadership characteristics and the second article will address the technical project management competencies. The questions are tailored for an IT interview; however, they could be modified based on industry. They are open-ended and will help shape the conversation.
 
Leadership Behaviors
Question 1: Describe a recent project where you were responsible for managing multiple people or teams. What were some of the key challenges and how did you handle those challenges?
 
This question demonstrates a result-oriented leadership behavior. Project managers need to demonstrate delivery and a desire to attain the end goal. Staffing project managers who simply point out problems but do not help resolve them will not drive the project to completion. Effective project managers demonstrate how they’ve managed a project, coordinated across multiple teams, overcame obstacles and delivered the project’s goals.
 
Question 2: Describe a time when you implemented a new idea without being asked or pursued a new opportunity that could improve the project or company.
 
Demonstrating courage and a willingness to take action without being asked is a key delivery characteristic of effective project managers. Project sponsors entrust the project’s goals, budget and their own reputations on their project managers. Project sponsors don’t have all the answers and need intelligent and motivated people to solve problems, identify new opportunities and take action without being prompted.
 
Question 3: Describe a scenario where you had to balance competing customer demands with project constraints. How did you ensure customer satisfaction while maintaining the goals of the project?
 
Maintaining a customer focused approach while ensuring the project deliverables are completed on time is a delicate balance. Business partners don’t understand all the technical details required to turn business processes into software solutions. They just want the system to work and accommodate their changing business needs. Effective project managers build rapport with their business partners, seek to understand the underlying needs and proactively address their concerns. It is a difficult balance as project managers commit to delivering the project scope while addressing a business customer’s changing requirements.
 
Question 4: Describe a time when you had to balance quality management with a challenged project schedule.
 
As projects execute and schedule variances occur, there is a tendency to shorten the quality testing cycle to maintain a project end date. In some projects, the end date can be extended, and in other projects the end date must be maintained. Effective project managers recognize the importance of quality management in the software development cycle and prioritize the test cases and test cycles that deliver the project’s critical functionality. These project managers successfully commit to a quality mindset and ensure defects are resolved or mitigated.
 
The project manager should also recognize the challenge of managing the triple constraint and maintain a commitment to quality. Recognizing delays in the schedule early will help project managers adjust testing schedules so the support team isn’t called in from a day off or a holiday.
 
Question 5: Describe a time when you had a difficult situation working with a vendor or another peer? What was your approach to resolve the issues while maintaining a positive relationship?
 
Without a cohesive team, a project manager can not be effective. Projects often depend on vendors and supplier team members to provide services. The nature of the client-vendor relationship emphasizes mutually beneficial goals. However, the vendor doesn’t always prioritize the client’s interests as heavily as their own. The ability to effectively develop teams across corporate borders is critical to project delivery. Clients will always try to maximize services at a minimal cost while vendors are motivated to increase costs for additional services.
 
In a challenged project with strained vendor relationships, it becomes even more important to focus on the critical issues to work together and deliver the end goal. The same skill is needed when working with other peers who are not necessarily motivated to help the project team. Strong relationships help solve problems and support project delivery. The best project management system, tools and techniques cannot replace the power effective relationships have across multiple teams.
 
Assessing Communication Skills
In this set of interview questions, there is not a specific question that addresses the project manager’s communication skill or style. The open-ended questions provide the interviewer with enough feedback to determine how well the candidate communicates using verbal and non-verbal communication. Communication is 90 percent of a project manager’s job, and interviewers should look for project managers who can logically and clearly respond to the interview questions as well as demonstrate project management theory in practice.
 
These leadership behavior-based questions are just a few examples that identify a project manager’s drive for results, commitment to customer satisfaction and focus on quality delivery. The next article will provide a set of technical project management assessment questions.
 
This article was written by Andy Makar and originally appeared on Gantthead.com
Last Updated ( Saturday, 15 November 2008 )
 
Joomla Templates by Joomlashack